This relaxes error encountered during lfs3_mtree_gc to _not_ propagate,
but instead just log a warning and prevent the relevant work from being
checked off during EOT.
The idea is this allows other work to make progress in low-space
conditions.
I originally meant to limit this to gbmap repopulations, to match the
behavior of lfs3_alloc_repopgbmap, but I think extending the idea to all
filesystem mutating operations makes sense (LFS3_T_MKCONSISTENT +
LFS3_T_REPOPGBMAP + LFS3_T_COMPACTMETA).
---
To avoid incorrectly marking traversal work as completed, we need to
track if we hit any ENOSPC errors, thus the new LFS3_t_NOSPC flag:
LFS3_t_NOSPC 0x00800000 Optional gc work ran out of space
Not the happiest just throwing flags at problems, but I can't think of a
better solution at the moment.
This doesn't differentiate between ENOSPC errors during the different
types of work, but in theory if we're hitting ENOSPC errors whatever
work returns the error is a toss-up anyways.
---
Adds a bit of code:
code stack ctx
before: 37208 2352 688
after: 37248 (+0.1%) 2352 (+0.0%) 688 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 40120 2368 856
gbmap after: 40204 (+0.2%) 2368 (+0.0%) 856 (+0.0%)
These are more-or-less equivalent, but:
- Making lfs3_alloc_zerogbmap a non-gbmap function avoids awkward
conversations about why it's not atomic.
- Making lfs3_alloc_zerogbmap alloc-specific makes room for pererased-
specific zeroing operations that we might need when adopt bmerased
ranges (future).
No code changes, which means const-propagation works as expected:
code stack ctx
before: 37208 2352 688
after: 37208 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 688 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 40120 2368 856
gbmap after: 40120 (+0.0%) 2368 (+0.0%) 856 (+0.0%)
Unfortunately this doesn't work and will need to be ripped-out/reverted.
---
The goal was to limit in-use -> free zeroing to the uknown window, which
would allow the gbmap to be updated in-place, saving the extra RAM we
need to maintain the extra gbmap snapshot during traversals and
lfs3_alloc_zerogbmap.
Unfortunately this doesn't seem to work. If we limit zeroing to the
unknown window, blocks can get stuck in the in-use state as long as they
stay in the known window. Since the gbmap's known window encompasses
most of the disk, this can cause the allocators to lock up and be unable
to make progress.
So will revert, but committing the current implementation in case we
revisit the idea.
As a plus, reverting avoids needing to maintain this unknown window
logic, which is tricky and error-prone.
To allow relaxing when LFS3_I_REPOPLOOKAHEAD and LFS3_I_REPOPGBMAP will
be set, potentially reducing gc workload after allocating only a couple
blocks.
The relevant cfg comments have quite a bit more info.
Note -1 (not the default, 0, maybe we should explicitly flip this?)
restores the previous functionality of setting these flags on the first
block allocation.
---
Also tweaked gbmap repops during gc/traversals to _not_ try to repop
unless LFS3_I_REPOPGBMAP is set. We probably should have done this from
the beginning since repopulating the gbmap writes to disk and is
potentially destructive.
Adds code, though hopefully we can claw this back with future config
rework:
code stack ctx
before: 37176 2352 684
after: 37208 (+0.1%) 2352 (+0.0%) 688 (+0.6%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 40024 2368 848
gbmap after: 40120 (+0.2%) 2368 (+0.0%) 856 (+0.9%)
This is an alias for all possible gc work, which is a bit more
complicated than you might think due to compile-time features (example:
LFS3_GC_REPOPGBMAP).
The intention is to make loops like the following easy to write:
struct lfs3_fsinfo fsinfo;
lfs3_fs_stat(&lfs3, &fsinfo) => 0;
lfs3_trv_t trv;
lfs3_trv_open(&lfs3, &trv, fsinfo.flags & LFS3_GC_ALL) => 0;
...
It's possible to do this by explicitly setting all gc flags, but that
requires quite a bit of knowledge from the user.
Another option is allowing -1 for gc/traversal flags, but that loses
assert protection against unknown/misplaced flags.
---
This raises more questions about the prefix naming: it feels a bit weird
to take LFS3_I_* flags, mask with LFS3_GC_* flags, and pass them as
LFS3_T_* flags, but it gets the job done.
Limiting LFS3_GC_ALL to the LFS3_GC_* namespace avoids issues with
opt-out/mode flags such as LFS3_T_RDONLY, LFS3_T_MTREEONLY, etc. For
this reason it probably doesn't make sense to add something similar to
the other namespaces.
- LFS3_T_COMPACT -> LFS3_T_COMPACTMETA
- gc_compact_thresh -> gc_compactmeta_thresh
And friends:
LFS3_M_COMPACTMETA 0x00000800 Compact metadata logs
LFS3_GC_COMPACTMETA 0x00000800 Compact metadata logs
LFS3_I_COMPACTMETA 0x00000800 Filesystem may have uncompacted metadata
LFS3_T_COMPACTMETA 0x00000800 Compact metadata logs
---
This does two things:
1. Highlights that LFS3_T_COMPACTMETA only interacts with metadata logs,
and has no effect on data blocks.
2. Better matches the verb+noun names used for other gc/traversal flags
(REPOPGBMAP, CKMETA, etc).
It is a bit more of a mouthful, but I'm not sure that's entirely a bad
thing. These are pretty low-level flags.
And friends:
LFS3_M_REPOPLOOKAHEAD 0x00000200 Repopulate lookahead buffer
LFS3_GC_REPOPLOOKAHEAD 0x00000200 Repopulate lookahead buffer
LFS3_I_REPOPLOOKAHEAD 0x00000200 Lookahead buffer is not full
LFS3_T_REPOPLOOKAHEAD 0x00000200 Repopulate lookahead buffer
To match LFS3_T_REPOPGBMAP, which is more-or-less the same operation.
Though this does turn into quite the mouthful...
There's a strong argument for naming this inline_size as that's more
likely what users expect, but shrub_size is just the more correct name
and avoids confusion around having multiple names for the same thing.
It also highlights that shrubs in littlefs3 are a bit different than
inline files in littlefs2, and that this config also affects large files
with a shrubbed root.
May rerevert this in the future, but probably only if there is
significant user confusion.
And tweaked a few related comments.
I'm still on the fence with this name, I don't think it's great, but it
at least betters describes the "repopulation" operation than
"rebuilding". The important distinction is that we don't throw away
information. Bad/erased block info (future) is still carried over into
the new gbmap snapshot, and persists unless you explicitly call
rmgbmap + mkgbmap.
So, adopting gbmap_repop_thresh for now to see if it's just a habit
thing, but may adopt a different name in the future.
As a plus, gbmap_repop_thresh is two characters shorter.
A big downside of LFS3_T_REBUILDGBMAP is the addition of an lfs3_btree_t
struct to _every_ traversal object.
Unfortunately, I don't see a way around this. We need to track the new
gbmap snapshot _somewhere_, and other options (such as a global gbmap.b_
snapshot) just move the RAM around without actually saving anything.
To at least mitigate this internally, this splits lfs3_trv_t into
distinct lfs3_trv_t, lfs3_mgc_t, and lfs3_mtrv_t structs that capture
only the relevant state for internal traversal layers:
- lfs3_mtree_traverse <- lfs3_mtrv_t
- lfs3_mtree_gc <- lfs3_mgc_t (contains lfs3_mtrv_t)
- lfs3_trv_read <- lfs3_trv_t (contains lfs3_mgc_t)
This minimizes the impact of the gbmap rebuild snapshots, and saves a
big chunk of RAM. As a plus it also saves RAM in the default build by
limiting the 2-block block queue to the high-level lfs3_trv_read API:
code stack ctx
before: 37176 2360 684
after: 37176 (+0.0%) 2352 (-0.3%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 40060 2432 848
gbmap after: 40024 (-0.1%) 2368 (-2.6%) 848 (+0.0%)
The main downside? Our field names are continuing in their
ridiculousness:
lfs3.gc.gc.t.b.h.flags // where else would the global gc flags be?
A bit less simplified than I hoped, we don't _strictly_ need both
LFS3_t_DIRTY + LFS3_t_MUTATED if we're ok with either (1) making
multiple passes to confirm fixorphans succeeded or (2) clear the COMPACT
flag after one pass (which may introduce new uncompacted metadata). But
both of these have downsides, and we're not _that_ stressed for flag
space yet...
So keeping all three of:
LFS3_t_DIRTY 0x04000000 Filesystem modified outside traversal
LFS3_t_MUTATED 0x02000000 Filesystem modified during traversal
LFS3_t_CKPOINTED 0x01000000 Filesystem ckpointed during traversal
But I did manage to get rid of the bit swapping by tweaking LFS3_t_DIRTY
to imply LFS3_t_MUTATED instead of being exclusive. This removes the
"failed" gotos in lfs3_mtree_gc and makes things a bit more readable.
---
I also split lfs3_fs/handle_clobber into separate lfs3_fs/handle_clobber
and lfs3_fs/handle_mutate functions. This added a bit of code, but I
think is worth it for a simpler internal API. A confusing internal API
is no good.
In total these simplifications saved a bit of code:
code stack ctx
before: 37208 2360 684
after: 37176 (-0.1%) 2360 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 40100 2432 848
gbmap after: 40060 (-0.1%) 2432 (+0.0%) 848 (+0.0%)
- lfs3_gbmap_set* -> lfs3_gbmap_mark*
- lfs3_alloc_markfree -> lfs3_alloc_adopt
- lfs3_alloc_mark* -> lfs3_alloc_markinuse*
Mainly for consistency, since the gbmap and lookahead buffer are more or
less the same algorithm, ignoring nuances (lookahead only ors inuse
bits, gbmap rebuilding can result in multiple snapshots, etc).
The rename lfs3_gbmap_set* -> lfs3_gbmap_mark* also makes space for
lfs3_gbmap_set* to be used for range assignments with a payload, which
may be useful for erased ranges (gbmap tracked ecksums?)
This adds LFS3_T_REBUILDGBMAP and friends, and enables incremental gbmap
rebuilds as a part of gc/traversal work:
LFS3_M_REBUILDGBMAP 0x00000400 Rebuild the gbmap
LFS3_GC_REBUILDGBMAP 0x00000400 Rebuild the gbmap
LFS3_I_REBUILDGBMAP 0x00000400 The gbmap is not full
LFS3_T_REBUILDGBMAP 0x00000400 Rebuild the gbmap
On paper, this is more or less identical to repopulating the lookahead
buffer -- traverse the filesystem, mark blocks as in-use, adopt the new
gbmap/lookahead buffer on success -- but a couple nuances make
rebuilding the gbmap a bit trickier:
- Unlike the lookahead buffer, which eagerly zeros in allocation, we
need an explicit zeroing pass before we start marking blocks as
in-use. This means multiple traversals can potentially conflict with
each other, risking the adoption of a clobbered gbmap.
- The gbmap, which stores information on disk, relies on block
allocation and the temporary "in-flight window" defined by allocator
ckpoints to avoid circular block states during gbmap rebuilds. This
makes gbmap rebuilds sensitive to allocator ckpoints, which we
consider more-or-less a noop in other parts of the system.
Though now that I'm writing this, it might have been possible to
instead include gbmap rebuild snapshots in fs traversals... but that
would probably have been much more complicated.
- Rebuilding the gbmap requires writing to disk and is generally much
more expensive/destructive. We want to avoid trying to rebuild the
gbmap when it's not possible to actually make progress.
On top of this, the current trv-clobber system is a delicate,
error-prone mess.
---
To simplify everything related to gbmap rebuilds, I added a new
internal traversal flag: LFS3_t_CKPOINTED:
LFS3_t_CKPOINTED 0x04000000 Filesystem ckpointed during traversal
LFS3_t_CKPOINTED is set, unconditionally, on all open traversals in
lfs3_alloc_ckpoint, and provides a simple, robust mechanism for checking
if _any_ allocator checkpoints have occured since a traversal was
started. Since lfs3_alloc_ckpoint is required before any block
allocation, this provides a strong guarantee that nothing funny happened
to any allocator state during a traversal.
This makes lfs3_alloc_ckpoint a bit less cheap, but the strong
guarantees that allocator state is unmodified during traversal are well
worth it.
This makes both lookahead and gbmap passes simpler, safer, and easier to
reason about.
I'd like to adopt something similar+stronger for LFs3_t_MUTATED, and
reduce this back to two flags, but that can be a future commit.
---
Unfortunately due to the potential for recursion, this ended up reusing
less logic between lfs3_alloc_rebuildgbmap and lfs3_mtree_gc than I had
hoped, but at like the main chunks (lfs3_alloc_remap,
lfs3_gbmap_setbptr, lfs3_alloc_adoptgbmap) could be split out into
common functions.
The result is a decent chunk of code and stack, but the value is high as
incremental gbmap rebuilds are the only option to reduce the latency
spikes introduced by the gbmap allocator (it's not significantly worse
than the lookahead buffer, but both do require traversing the entire
filesystem):
code stack ctx
before: 37164 2352 684
after: 37208 (+0.1%) 2360 (+0.3%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 39708 2376 848
gbmap after: 40100 (+1.0%) 2432 (+2.4%) 848 (+0.0%)
Note the gbmap build is now measured with LFS3_GBMAP=1, instead of
LFS3_YES_GBMAP=1 (maybe-gbmap) as before. This includes the cost of
mkgbmap, lfs3_f_isgbmap, etc.
And:
- Tweaked the behavior of gbmap.window/known to _not_ match disk.
gbmap.known matching disk is what required a separate
lookahead.bmapped in the first place, but we never use both fields.
- _Don't_ revert gbmap on failed mdir commits!
This was broken! If we reverted we risked inheriting outdated
in-flight block information.
This could be fixed by also zeroing lookahead.bmapped, but would force
a gbmap rebuild. And why? The only interaction between mdir commit and
the gbmap is block allocation, which is intentionally allowed to go
out-of-sync to relax issues like this.
Note we still revert in lfs3_fs_grow, the new gbmap we create there is
incompatible with the previous disk size.
As a part of these changes, gbmap.window now behaves roughly the same as
gbmap.known and updates eagerly on block allocation.
This makes lookahead.window and gbmap.window somewhat redundant, but
simplifies the relevant logic (especially due to how lookahead.window
lags behind lookahead.off).
---
A bunch of bugs fell out-of-this, the interactions with lfs3_fs_mkgbmap
and lfs3_fs_grow being especially tricky, but fortunately our testing is
doing a good job.
At least the code changes were minimal, saves a bit of RAM:
code stack ctx
no-gbmap before: 37168 2352 684
no-gbmap after: 37168 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
maybe-gbmap before: 39688 2392 852
maybe-gbmap after: 39720 (+0.1%) 2376 (-0.7%) 848 (-0.5%)
code stack ctx
yes-gbmap before: 39156 2392 852
yes-gbmap after: 39208 (+0.1%) 2376 (-0.7%) 848 (-0.5%)
These two functions allow changing whether or not the gbmap is in use
after format:
// Enable the global on-disk block-map
//
// Returns a negative error code on failure. Does nothing if a gbmap
// already exists.
int lfs3_fs_mkgbmap(lfs3_t *lfs3);
// Disable the global on-disk block-map
//
// Returns a negative error code on failure. Does nothing if no gbmap
// is found.
int lfs3_fs_rmgbmap(lfs3_t *lfs3);
rmgbmap was easy enough, but implementing mkgbmap turned out to be
surprisingly tricky due to how gstate permeates the system:
- Even if we zero gstate when we removing the gbmap, mounting the
image on a driver that doesn't understand the gbmap results in garbage
gstate over time as mdir compacts drop unknown gdeltas.
I think this sort of implicit gdelta cleanup is a good thing, but the
possibility of garbage gstate is a bit annoying.
Example A: the dbg scripts are currently printing a bunch of warnings
for corrupt gstate that can be safely ignored.
To support recovering from garbage gstate in mkgbmap, I changed
lfs3_fs_commitgdelta to _always_ track p state even when disabled. We
already needed to do this in lfs3_fs_flush/consumegdelta anyways,
since we don't know if the gbmap is used until parsing wcompat flags.
- The commit that enables the gbmap is tricky. We need the gbmap enabled
to calculate the new gdelta, but we also need it disabled so we don't
traverse the existing gbmap_p (which may be garbage).
As a workaround I added gbmap.b_p, which is in theory redundant with
gbmap_p, but (1) avoids needing to decode gbmap_p during traversals,
and (2) allows the two to temporarily fall out-of-sync in mkgbmap.
This means we potentially have 5 (!) snaphots flying around when
rebuilding the gbmap, which is starting to get a bit silly. But this
was also motivated by gbmap_p decoding adding roughly the same amount
of RAM to lfs3_mtree_traverse_, so the total RAM usage should in
theory be roughly the same.
There might be a better solution, but this at least gets mkgbmap
working. The gbmap builds are not our most RAM senstive configurations
anyways.
---
Also added a couple more tests in test_gbmap to test these:
- test_gbmap_files
- test_gbmap_rmgbmap
- test_gbmap_mkgbmap
- test_gbmap_rmmkgbmap
- test_gbmap_mkrmgbmap
And an explicit wraparound test to test_alloc. This was loosely implied
by the nospc tests, but it's probably better to have an explicit test.
The only downside is this implementation is limited to files:
- test_alloc_wraparound_files
---
Note we are currently dealing with three different configurations:
no-gbmap (the default), yes-gbmap (LFS3_YES_GBMAP), and maybe-gbmap
(LFS3_GBMAP + LFS3_F_GBMAP at runtime).
It only makes sense to include these in maybe-gbmap mode, so this is the
only mode with a notable code increase. However these functions are
relatively cheap. The stack/ctx changes also affect yes-gbmap, but
should mostly cancel out, see above:
code stack ctx
no-gbmap before: 37168 2352 684
no-gbmap after: 37168 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
maybe-gbmap before: 39292 2456 800
maybe-gbmap after: 39688 (+1.0%) 2392 (-2.6%) 852 (+6.5%)
code stack ctx
yes-gbmap before: 39116 2456 800
yes-gbmap after: 39156 (+0.1%) 2392 (-2.6%) 852 (+6.5%)
In lfs3_fs_grow, we need to update any gbmaps to match the new disk
size. The actual patch to the gbmap is easy, but it does get a bit
delicate since we need to feed the gbmap with an allocator in the new
disk size.
Fortunately, the opportunistism of the gbmap allocator avoids any
catch-22 issues, as long as we make sure to not trigger any gbmap
rebuilds.
Adds a bit of code, but not much:
code stack ctx
before: 37168 2352 684
after: 37168 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 39000 2456 800
gbmap after: 39116 (+0.3%) 2456 (+0.0%) 800 (+0.0%)
Highlighted by the gbmap work, the need for every btree commit to claim
(mark as unfetched, forcing erased-state to be rechecked) every possible
btree snapshot is tedious and error prone.
Unfortunately we can't avoid this for in-flight/stack allocated btrees,
but we can at least automatically claim the global/tracked btrees
(mtree, gbmap, and file btrees) in lfs3_btree_commit_. This makes most
btree commits just do the right thing, and hopefully minimizes the
risk of forgetting a necessary btree claim.
It also cleans up the various btree-specific claims we were doing, and
makes the codebase a bit less of a mess.
---
Also fixed bshrubs never claiming cached leaves. We now also claim
bshrubs (not just btrees), but avoid clobbering erased-state with
is-shrub checks in lfs3_btree_claim.
Code changes minor, btree claims are at least a cheap operation:
code stack ctx
before: 37172 2352 684
after: 37168 (-0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 38996 2456 800
gbmap after: 39000 (+0.0%) 2456 (+0.0%) 800 (+0.0%)
This rearranges lfs3_gbmap_set_ a bit to try to minimize the number of
commits necessary for gbmap updates.
By combining the split and range creation, we can reduce the common
no-merge case to a single commit.
This matters quite a bit because rebuilding the gbmap requires a ton of
lfs3_gbmap_set_ calls (~2d).
---
The original idea was to see if adopting a builder pattern (see
lfs3_file_graft_) here would reduce the commits necessary, but I don't
think it can. Worst case we need to delete 3 ranges, and since they can
reside in different btree leaves, this requires 3 separate commits.
And the current implementation uses no worse than 3 commits.
---
Code changes minimal:
code stack ctx
before: 37172 2352 684
after: 37172 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 38992 2456 800
gbmap after: 38996 (+0.0%) 2456 (+0.0%) 800 (+0.0%)
This changes the gbmap rebuild strategy to clear in-use ranges from a
snapshot of the old gbmap instead of building a new gbmap from scratch.
The theory of building a new gbmap from scratch is it skips the cost of
clearing in-use ranges, but:
1. This potentially misses out on erased-state still in the gbmap.
2. We would need to copy over any erased/bad state (not yet implemented)
before traversing, and reusing the old gbmap makes this a bit
simpler.
To make this a little bit more efficient, I extended lfs3_gbmap_set_ to
accept a weight, however this is limited to modifying only a single
range. Cross-range sets would be quite a bit more complicated (see file
grafting).
We're probably dominated by the per-block set operation during traversal
anyways.
---
Costs a bit of code, but in theory makes erased/bad block tracking
cheaper:
code stack ctx
before: 37172 2352 684
after: 37172 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
gbmap before: 38852 2456 800
gbmap after: 38992 (+0.4%) 2456 (+0.0%) 800 (+0.0%)
I think a good rule of thumb is if you refer to some variable/config/
field with a different name in comments/writing/etc more often than not,
you should just rename the variable/config/field to match.
So yeah, gbmap_rebuild_thresh controls when the gbmap is rebuilt.
Also touched up the doc comment a bit.
Just cleaning up a bunch of outdated TODOs and commented out code, as
well as a little bit of code formatting, and scrubbing airspace/gbatc
names as these are no longer used and will just confuse new users.
Having gbmap/bmap used in different places for the same thing was
confusing. Preferring gbmap as it is consistent with other gstate (grm
queue, gcksums), even if it is a bit noisy.
It's interesting to note what didn't change:
- The BM* range tags: LFS3_TAG_BMFREE, etc. These already differs from
the GBMAP* prefix enough, and adopting GBM* would risk confusion for
actual gstate.
- The gbmap revdbg string: "bb~r". We don't have enough characters for
anything else!
- dbgbmap.py/dbgbmapsvg.py. These aren't actually related to the gbmap,
so the name difference is a good thing.
TLDR: This drops the idea of different bmap strategies/modes, and sorts
out most of the compile-time/runtime conditional bmap interactions.
---
Motivation: Benchmarking (at least up to the 32-bit word limit) has
shown the bmap will unlikely be a significant bottleneck, even on large
disks. The largest disks tend to be NAND, and NAND's ridiculous block
size limits pressure on block allocation.
There are still concerns for areas I haven't measured yet:
- SD/eMMC/FTL - Small blocks, so more pressure on block allocation. In
theory the logical block size can be artificially increased, but this
comes with a granularity tradeoff.
- I've only measured throughput, latency is a whole other story.
However, users have reported lfs3_fs_gc is useful for mitigating this,
so maybe latency is less of a concern now?
But while there may still be room for improvement via alternative bmap
strategies, the risk a concerning amount of complexity. Yes,
configuration gets more complicated, but the real issue is any bmap
strategies that try to track _deallocations_ (the original idea being
treediffing) risk falling leaking blocks if all cases aren't covered.
The current "bmap cache" strategy strikes a really nice balance where it
reduces _amortized_ block allocation -> ~O(log n) without RAM, while
retaining the safe, bug-resistant, single-source-of-truth properties
that come with lookahead-based allocation.
---
So, long story short, dropping other strategies, and now the presence of
the bmap is a boolean flag.
This is also the first format-specific flag:
- Define LFS3_BMAP to enable the bmap logic, but note by default the
bmap will still not be used.
- Define LFS3_YES_BMAP to force the bmap to be used.
- With LFS3_BMAP, passing LFS3_F_GBMAP to lfs3_format will include the
on-disk block-map.
- No flag is needed during mount, the presence of the bmap is determined
by the on-disk wcompat flags (LFS3_WCOMPAT_GBMAP). This also prevents
rw mounting if the bmap is not supported, but rdonly mounting is
allowed.
- Users can check if the bmap is in use via lfs3_fs_stat, which reports
LFS3_I_GBMAP in the flags field.
There's still some missing pieces, but these will be a bit more
involved:
- lfs3_fs_grow needs to be made bmap aware!
- We probably want something like lfs3_fs_mkgbmap and lfs3_fs_rmgbmap to
allow converting between bmap backed/not-backed filesystem images.
Code changes minimal:
code stack ctx
before: 37172 2352 684
after: 37172 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
bmap before: 38844 2456 800
bmap after: 38852 (+0.0%) 2456 (+0.0%) 800 (+0.0%)
It makes sense, nesting directives (#ifdef) in macro arguments invites
all sort of weird parse errors. Unfortunately, this doesn't leave us
with many options for conditionally including rattrs in LFS3_RATTRS
lists... This is especially important for lfs3_format, where we can
expect many rattrs to depend on compile-time configurations.
To fix the warning, I went ahead and adopted a conditionally predefined
LFS3_RATTR_IFDEF_BMAP before the rattr list. I'm not super happy with
this fix (ugh, missing comma), but it at least avoids a warning and
non-portable behavior.
New bmap range tags:
LFS3_TAG_BMRANGE 0x033u v--- --11 --11 uuuu
LFS3_TAG_BMFREE 0x0330 v--- --11 --11 ----
LFS3_TAG_BMINUSE 0x0331 v--- --11 --11 ---1
LFS3_TAG_BMERASED 0x0332 v--- --11 --11 --1-
LFS3_TAG_BMBAD 0x0333 v--- --11 --11 --11
Note 0x334-0x33f are still reserved for future bmap tags, but the new
encoding fits in the surprisingly common 2-bit subfield that may
deduplicate some decoding code.
Fitting in 2-bits is the main reason for this, now that in-flight ranges
look like they won't be worth exploring further. Worst case we can
always add more bm tags in the future. And it may even make sense to use
an entire bit for in-flight tags, since in theory the concept can apply
to more than just in-use blocks.
---
Another benefit of this encoding: In-use vs free is a bit check, and I
like the implication that an in-use + erased block can only be a bad
block.
No code changes:
code stack ctx
before: 37172 2352 684
after: 37172 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
bmap before: 38844 2456 800
bmap after: 38844 (+0.0%) 2456 (+0.0%) 800 (+0.0%)
So now:
lfs3.c:11482:info: Rebuilding bmap (bmap 37/256)
lfs3.c:11246:error: No more free space (lookahead 0/256)
Instead of the previously somewhat confusing:
lfs3.c:11484:info: Rebuilding bmap (bmap 62/256/256)
lfs3.c:11247:error: No more free space (lookahead 0/0/256)
While the previous info statements did have more info (window +
ckpoint + block count), usually one of these ended up redundant
(window == ckpoint == 0 during ENOSPC, for example).
If before rebuilding the bmap is a valid checkpoint, after is too.
This lets us realloc any blocks that may have been temporarily allocated
when rebuilding the bmap. This probably doesn't matter much except for
low-storage states when blocks are extremely scarce, but allocator
checkpoints are cheap so better safe than sorry.
Code changes minimal (negative?):
code stack ctx
before: 37172 2352 684
after: 37172 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
bmap before: 38852 2456 800
bmap after: 38844 (-0.0%) 2456 (+0.0%) 800 (+0.0%)
I've had this trick in my back pocket for a while, but didn't think it
would be worth the code cost. Benchmarks suggested this was a
bottleneck, so gave it an impl...
But it turned out to be a red herring...
At least the code cost is ridiculously cheap?
code stack ctx
before: 37156 2352 684
after: 37172 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
Oh, sidenote, this also removes shrub trunk fetching, repurposing that
bit as an internal flag for quick-fetches. I don't think fetching shrubs
makes sense anymore? This code was probably leftover from a less-correct
traversal implementation.
---
The basic idea: the most recent trunk contains all the info we need to
fetch a btree node for committing:
- We can infer the rbyd weight from one trunk: The total weight is just
the sum of alt pointer weights + the leaf weight.
- The checksum tags provide the perturb bit, ecksum, etc.
The only thing we can't find from the most recent trunk is the checksum,
but this is already implicit in our CoW branch pointers! (Technically the
weight is as well, but we have to scan the alts anyways.)
So we don't need to scan the entire rbyd if we know the checksum, just
the most recent trunk + checksum tags.
In theory, quick-fetches drop our btree commit runtime from
O(b log_b n + (log b)(log_b^2 n)) -> O((log b)(log_b^2 n)).
---
In practice, this doesn't seem to matter, even on NAND with 128KiB
blocks. We're still dominated by compaction costs, perhaps due to the
poor granularity of NAND's read size?
I'm going to keep this for now just for the peace-of-mind while
benchmarking, but it may be worth removing in the future (or maybe not?
the code size is much less than I was expecting).
At least it simplifies the runtime complexity...
After sleeping on it, allowing crystal_thresh < prog_size makes more
sense than I initially thought, if only to better support the case where
prog_size = block_size (SD/eMMC).
It's true fragments + crystal_thresh were intended to avoid needing to
write padding to raw data blocks, but this only makes sense up until
block padding is cheaper than rbyd overheads. At ~block_size/4, rbyds vs
padded data blocks have roughly the same cost, and at ~block_size/2
rbyds use ~2x the storage due to logging/splitting. At ~block_size/2 we
definitely want to crystallize even if this is still below prog_size.
And it turns out allowing crystal_thresh < prog_size fixes the 512B
block size issues on SD/eMMC we were running into earlier!
---
Implementing this required some tweaks to lfs3_file_crystallize_:
1. We intentionally do not align down partial crystallizations if we
can't satisfy prog alignment, as we risk making no progress
in this case.
2. If we can't satisfy prog alignment, don't mark the bptr as erased.
Resuming crystallization to an unaligned block is an error.
Unaligned progs should already be implicitly padded by the lower bd
caching logic, so not aligning should be all we need to do to pad data
blocks.
Oh, and also relax the crystal_thresh >= prog_size constraints.
Adds a bit of code, but the improved block usage on SD/eMMC will
hopefully be valuable:
code stack ctx
before: 37112 2352 684
after: 37156 (+0.1%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
I confused myself a bit while benchmarking because crystal_thresh <
prog_size was showing some very confusing results. But it turns out the
relevant code was just not written well enough to support this
configuration.
And, to be fair, this configuration really doesn't make sense. The whole
point of the fragment + crystallization system is so we never have to
write unaligned data to blocks. I mean, we could explicitly write
padding in this case, but why?
---
This should probably eventually be either an assert or mutable limit,
but in the meantime I'm just adjusting crystal_thresh at runtime, which
adds a bit of code:
code stack ctx
before: 37076 2352 684
after: 37112 (+0.1%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
On the plus side, this prevents crystal_thresh=0 issues much more
elegantly.
When crystal_thresh < fragment_size, there was a risk that repeated
write operations would oscillate between crystallizing and fragmenting
every operation. Not only would this wreck performance, it would also
violently wear down blocks as each crystallization would trigger an
erase.
Fortunately all we need to do to prevent this is check both
fragment_size and crystal_thresh before fragmenting. Note this also
affects the fragment checks in truncate/fruncate.
---
crystal_thresh < fragment_size is kind of a weird configuration, to be
honest we should probably just assert if configured this way (we never
write fragments > crystal_thresh, because at that point we would just
crystallize).
But at the moment the extra leniency is useful for benchmarking.
Adds a bit of code, but will probably either assert or mutably limit in
the future:
code stack ctx
before: 37028 2352 684
after: 37076 (+0.1%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
There was a mismatch between the lfs3_cfg comment and the actual
crystal_thresh math where crystal_thresh=0 would break things:
- In lfs3_file_flush_, crystal_thresh=0 meant we would never resume
crystallization, leading to terrible, _terrible_, linear write
performance.
- In lfs3_file_sync and lfs3_set, it's unclear if small file commit
optimizations were working properly. I went ahead and added a
lfs3_max(lfs3->cfg->crystal_thresh, 1) just to be safe.
The other references to crystal_thresh all check for >= crystal_thresh
conditions, so shouldn't be broken (except for an unrelated bug in
lfs3_file_flushset_).
The reason for this is because crystal_thresh=1 is technically the lower
bound for this math. Allowing crystal_thresh=0 is just a convenience,
and honestly allowing it may have a been a bad idea. Maybe we should
require crystal_thresh=1 at minimum? I added a TODO.
All the new v3 config needs revisiting anyways, for defaults, etc.
---
Curiously, this actually saved code? My best guess is maybe some weird
code path in lfs3_file_flush_ was eliminated:
code stack ctx
before: 37036 2352 684
after: 37028 (-0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
This was a nasty performance hole found while benchmarking.
Basically, any time crystallization is triggered, the crystallization
algorithm tries to pack as much data into as few blocks as possible.
When fruncating (the common, and performance sensitive, use case being
logging), this can lead to the algorithm rewriting fruncated blocks.
What the crystallization algorithm doesn't realize, however, is that
when fruncating/logging, we're probably going to fruncate again on the
next call, so rewriting the block is a waste of effort.
Worst case -- a 1 block file -- this can cause littlefs to rewrite the
entire file on every append.
---
The solution implemented here, which is a bit of a hack, is to use the
actual block start for block alignment instead of the logical
start-of-block referenced by our btree/bshrub.
This solves the fruncating/logging performance hole, with the tradeoff
of using more storage than is strictly necessary. This tradeoff is
probably expected with logging however.
Code changes minimal:
code stack ctx
before: 37024 2352 684
after: 37036 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
We're not currently using these (at the moment it's unclear if the
original intention behind the treediff algorithms is worth pursuing),
and they are showing up in our heap benchmarks.
The good news is that means our heap benchmarks are working.
Also saves a bit of code/ctx in bmap mode:
code stack ctx
before: 37024 2352 684
after: 37024 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
bmap before: 38752 2456 812
bmap after: 38704 (-0.1%) 2456 (+0.0%) 800 (-1.5%)
Counterintuitively, LFS3_RDONLY + LFS3_BMAP _does_ make sense for cases
where you want to include the bmap in things like ckmeta/ckdata scans.
Though this is another argument for a LFS3_RDONLY + LFS3_NO_TRV build.
Traversals add quite a bit of code to the rdonly build that is probably
not always needed.
---
This just required another bunch of ifdefs.
Current bmap rdonly code size:
code stack ctx
rdonly: 10616 896 532
rdonly+bmap: 10892 (+2.6%) 896 (+0.0%) 636 (+19.5%)
Just a few alloc/eoff references slipped through in the bmap work.
Current rdonly code size:
code stack ctx
default: 37024 2352 684
rdonly: 10616 (-71.3%) 896 (-61.9%) 532 (-22.2%)
This biggest change was tweaking our mtortoise again to use the unused
trunk field for the power-of-two bound. The original intention of using
eoff was an extra precaution to avoid the mtortoise looking like a valid
shrub at any point, but eoff is not available in LFS3_RDONLY.
And we definitely want our mtortoise in LFS3_RDONLY!
---
Note I haven't actually tested LFS3_RDONLY + LFS3_BMAP. Does this config
even make sense? I guess ckmeta/ckdata will need to traverse the bmap,
so, counterintuitively, yes?
Whoops, this was an oversight when readopting lazy grafting.
It turns out the crystallization refactor that led to
lfs3_file_crystallize_ operating directly on file->leaf.bptr was a bit
incompatible with lazy grafting.
If we encounter an error and need to relocate, we need to rewrite any
data in our crystal, _including data in ungrafted leaves_.
By pure luck, the previous lazy grafting implementation side-stepped
this issue by including ungrafted leaves in lfs3_file_lookupnext calls.
This implicitly included the ungrafted leaf in any recrystallizations,
as long as it wasn't modified on error.
---
The fix required two tweaks:
- Recrystallize into a copy in case we hit an error.
Instead of a full lfs3_bptr_t, I just copied the relevant
block_/off_/pos_ pieces we need.
- Include file leaves in the crystallization logic.
Fortunately the multi-data-prioritization loop we already have for
any cached data was relatively easy to adapt for this.
As a plus lfs3_file_crystallize_ can also now short-circuit a
bshrub/btree lookup if the data we're crystallizing happens to be in the
file leaf.
This adds a bit more code, but doesn't break if we hit an error. In
theory this would add stack for the recrystallization copy, but
lfs3_file_crystallize_ is just off the stack hot-path:
code stack ctx
before: 36972 2352 684
after: 37024 (+0.1%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
Another fix I considered -- calling lfs3_file_graft on error -- may have
been a bit less code, but would have moved the stack hot-path under
lfs3_file_crystallize_. An error triggering _more_ progs/commits also
doesn't really sound like the greatest of ideas.
Found by test_ck_spam_fwrite_fuzz.
Saves a bit of code, at the cost of making this logic a bit more
difficult to read:
code stack ctx
before: 36992 2352 684
after: 36972 (-0.1%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
Now that ungrafted leaves are much more limited in scope, I'm not sure
lfs3_file_weight_ still makes sense as a separate function.
The only call was in lfs3_file_read, where we decide if we bother
flushing things before actually flushing things. Given that we should
now generally graft before expecting lfs3_file_lookupnext to make sense,
relying on lfs3_file_weight_ too much probably hints at a logic mistake.
This logic ends up inlined anyways, so no code changes:
code stack ctx
before: 36992 2352 684
after: 36992 (+0.0%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
We no longer need to discard the leaf, since we can just leave ungrafted
leaves around as long as LFS3_o_UNGRAFT is set.
This let's us flatten lfs3_file_crystallize_, saving a bit of code and
cleaning up the logic a bit:
code stack ctx
before: 37032 2352 684
after: 36992 (-0.1%) 2352 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
Note that lfs3_file_crystallize_ is still NOINLINE to force it off the
stack hot-path in lfs3_file_flush_, etc.
Continued benchmarking efforts are indicating this isn't really an
optional optimization.
This brings back lazy grafting, where the file leaf is allowed to fall
out-of-date to minimize bshrub/btree updates. This is controlled by
LFS3_o_UNGRAFT, which is similar, but independent from LFS3_o_UNCRYST:
- LFS3_o_UNCRYST - File's leaf not fully crystallized
- LFS3_o_UNGRAFT - File's leaf does not match disk
Note it makes sense for files to be UNGRAFT only, in the case where the
current crystal terminates at the end-of-file but future appends are
likely. And it makes sense for files to be UNCRYST only, in cases where
we graft uncrystallized blocks so the bshrub/btree makes sense.
Which brings us to the main change from the previous lazy-grafting
implementation: lfs3_file_lookupnext no longer includes ungrafted
leaves.
Instead, functions should call lfs3_file_graft if they need
lfs3_file_lookupnext to make sense.
This significantly reduces the code cost of lazy grafting, at the risk
of needing to graft more frequently. Fortunately we don't actually need
to call lfs3_file_graft all that often:
- lfs3_file_read already flushes caches/leaves before attempting any
bshrub/btree reads for simplicity (heavy are not currently considered
a priority, if you need this consider opening two file handles).
- lfs3_file_flush_ _does_ need to call lfs3_file_graft before the
crystallization heuristic pokes, but if we can't resume
crystallization, we would probably need to graft the crystal to
satisfy the flush anyways.
---
Lazy grafting, i.e. procrastinating on bshrub/btree updates during block
appends, is an optimization previously dropped due to perceived
nicheness:
- We can only lazily graft blocks, inlined data fragments always require
bshrub/btree updates since they live in the bshrub/btree.
- Sync forces bshrub/btree updates anyways, so lazy grafting has no
benefit for most logging applications.
- This performance penalty of eagerly grafting goes away if your caches
are large enough.
Note that the last argument is a non-argument in littlefs's case. They
whole point of littlefs is that you _don't_ need RAM to fix things.
However these arguments are all moot when you consider that the "niche
use case" -- linear file writes -- is the default bottleneck for most
applications. Any file operation becomes a linear write bottleneck when
the arguments are large enough. And this becomes a noticeable issue when
benchmarking.
So... This brings back lazy grafting. But with a more limited scope
w.r.t. internal file operations (the above lfs3_file_lookupnext/
lfs3_file_graft changes).
---
Long story short, lazy grafting is back again, reverting the ~3x
performance regression for linear file writes.
But now with quite a bit less code/stack cost:
code stack ctx
before: 36820 2368 684
after: 37032 (+0.6%) 2352 (-0.7%) 684 (+0.0%)
I was wrong! New bmaps containing the old bmap is _not_ sufficient for
lookahead scans, in the case where we rebuild the bmap multiple times
before an mdir commit! The previous bug with lfs3_trv_read +
lfs3_alloc_ckpoint _was_ a bug because the traversal was rdonly, but in
theory the bmap shouldn't have been corrupted.
Since this case is possible, we also need to traverse the on-disk bmap.
Fortunately only when the on-disk bmap does not match the active bmap.
This is probably safer behavior anyways, and means ckmeta/ckdata will
traverse both the in-RAM and on-disk bmaps, which is probably a good
thing in case we need to revert to the on-disk bmap due to power-loss/
error.
---
The implementation got a bit messy, since we only track the on-disk
encoding of the on-disk bmap (we need the encoding for gdeltas to work).
This ended up adding code, and an annoying (avoidable? TODO?) stack
cost, but correct behavior is better than incorrect behavior:
code stack ctx
before: 36856 2368 684
after: 36820 (-0.1%) 2368 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
bmap before: 38452 2400 812
bmap after: 38504 (+0.1%) 2464 (+2.7%) 812 (+0.0%)
Once again the inaccuracy of our stack frame calculations strike
again...
This was causing a problem where the bmap was being rebuilt on every
lfs3_trv_read, even though the traversal was opened LFS3_T_RDONLY!
Also added a note on why we don't need to traverse both the active and
on-disk bmaps. Counterintuitively, we don't need to because the new bmap
always contains the entirety of the on-disk bmap.
Code changes minimal:
code stack ctx
before: 36840 2368 684
after: 36856 (+0.0%) 2368 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
bmap before: 38440 2400 812
bmap after: 38452 (+0.0%) 2400 (+0.0%) 812 (+0.0%)
Found while benchmarking, our shrub estimates were being recalculated
much more frequently than they should be (every shrub commit). The
problem is that we never staged shrub estimates!
In theory this is fine, shrub estimates don't necessarily need staging.
We update shrub.r.eoff/estimate directly in lfs3_bshrub_commitroot_
after the mdir commit succeeds. But then we _redundantly_ sync
shrub_ -> shrub.r in lfs3_bshrub_commit. Since we never staged the
shrub estimate, we end up with garbage.
---
It's not clear to me this (staging the shrub estimate) is the best fix
for this, but the reason for the redundant shrub sync is the shared
bshrub/btree post-commit path. Added a TODO comment and should look at
this again when not in a time crunch.
Code changes minimal:
code stack ctx
before: 36836 2368 684
after: 36840 (+0.0%) 2368 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
Now that lfs3_alloc_ckpoint is more complicated, and can error, it makes
sense for lfs3_alloc_ckpoint to be implied by lfs3_mdir_commit.
Most lfs3_mdir_commit calls represent an atomic transaction from one
state -> another, so this saves a bit of code:
code stack ctx
before: 36912 2368 684
after: 36836 (-0.2%) 2368 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
bmap before: 38512 2400 812
bmap after: 38436 (-0.2%) 2400 (+0.0%) 812 (+0.0%)
The notable exception being bshrub-related commits in
lfs3_bshrub_commitroot_. Bshrub commits are trying to resolve an
in-flight btree, so the relevant blocks are very much _not_ at rest.
---
I've been hesitant to adopt this mostly just because it makes the
lfs3_mdir_commit* names even more of a mess:
- lfs3_mdir_commit__ -> lfs3_mdir_commit___
- lfs3_mdir_commit_ -> lfs3_mdir_commit__
- lfs3_mdir_commit -> lfs3_mdir_commit_
- added lfs3_mdir_commit
- lfs3_mdir_compact -> lfs3_mdir_compact_
- add lfs3_mdir_compact
- lfs3_mdir_alloc__ -> lfs3_mdir_alloc___
- lfs3_mdir_estimate__ -> lfs3_mdir_estimate___
- lfs3_mdir_swap__ -> lfs3_mdir_swap___
The main change is error propagation in lfs3_alloc_ckpoint. Since
lfs3_alloc_ckpoint writes to disk during bmap rebuilds, it can now fail
in all sorts of ways. Fortunately lfs3_alloc_ckpoint should only ever be
called by write operations, where these errors are be expected.
With bmap rebuild errors now reported correctly, this unblocks most of
the remaining test TODOs:
- Passing test_badblocks
- Passing test_ck
- Passing test_trvs
With this, LFS3_YES_BMAP is now passing all but two tests, which are
still ifndef-disabled as a temporary measure:
- test_btree - We make some low-level assumptions about the lookahead
allocator when testing btrees. It's probably not worth trying to get
this passing with the bmap allocator.
- test_grow - This one does need fixing! We currently don't update
on-disk bmaps correctly when growing the filesystem.
Code changes minimal:
code stack ctx
before: 36912 2368 684
after: 36912 (+0.0%) 2368 (+0.0%) 684 (+0.0%)
code stack ctx
bmap before: 38456 2400 812
bmap after: 38512 (+0.1%) 2400 (+0.0%) 812 (+0.0%)
Christopher Haster