This just provides a simple, easy-to-call, wrapper over the new
traversal API:
int lfsr_fs_gc(lfs_t *lfs, uint32_t flags);
The main difference from its previous incarnation, is that lfsr_fs_gc
now takes a flags argument to indicate exactly what gc operations to
perform. This gives the user more control, and may also make the API
more robust towards adding new features:
LFS_GC_MTREEONLY = 0x0010, // Only traverse the mtree
LFS_GC_MKCONSISTENT = 0x0020, // Make the filesystem consistent
LFS_GC_LOOKAHEAD = 0x0040, // Populate lookahead buffer
LFS_GC_COMPACT = 0x0080, // Compact metadata logs
LFS_GC_CKMETA = 0x0100, // Check metadata checksums
LFS_GC_CKDATA = 0x0200, // Check metadata + data checksums
LFS_GC_REPAIRMETA+ = 0x0400, // Repair metadata blocks
LFS_GC_REPAIRDATA+ = 0x0800, // Repair metadata + data blocks
+ Planned
Alternatively, gc_flags could have been added as a config option. But
making gc_flags a function argument matches other flag APIs (open
mainly), and is slightly more flexible in that it allows a system to do
different gc operations in different system states (though this could
also be accomplished with the hypothetical lfsr_fs_gccfg, which would
probably be good to add anyways).
Worst case, defining a system-wide define that you always pass to
lfsr_fs_gc accomplishes roughly the same thing.
---
This adds a bit more code, mainly to check if we actually need to
traverse, and to make sure traversals accomplish all of the requested
work.
code stack
before: 35448 2680
after: 35708 (+0.7%) 2672 (-0.3%)
Curiously it also saved a bit of stack, which is a bit silly given this
commit is purely code addition. Apparently something in lfs_alloc and
lfsr_fs_gc is shared, getting uninlined, and messing with the stack
measurement. lfs_alloc is quite sensitive to stack changes after all.
- LFS_O_FLUSH 0x0040 -> 0x0040
- LFS_O_SYNC 0x00c0 -> 0x0080
- LFS_T_CKMETA 0x0100 -> 0x0100
- LFS_T_CKDATA 0x0300 -> 0x0200
This is just simpler and should avoid any surprises for both devs and
users.
This has no impact on code size:
code stack
before: 35448 2680
after: 35448 (+0.0%) 2680 (+0.0%)
After thinking about this for a bit, there are some compelling
motivations for including an incremental LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT:
- Being able to run incremental LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT traversals in
parallel with read-only operations is actually quite enticing.
The only complicated part is maintaining the invalidatable traversal
state, which already exists with lfsr_traversal_t (except the
annoying LFS_F_MUTATED bit).
- While it's not really effective to combine LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT and
LFS_T_LOOKAHEAD traversals, it _is_ possible to combine
LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT with LFS_T_COMPACT, LFS_T_CKMETA,
LFS_T_REPAIRMETA (future), etc.
Really, LFS_T_LOOKAHEAD is the odd one out.
- Making LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT incremental means all filesystem-level
traversals (except lfsr_mount) can be run incrementally. Which is a
nice feature to have when O(n = entire fs) risks being very long
running.
The main downside of LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT (and LFS_T_COMPACT, etc) is that
attempting to run it immediately after mount will likely recursively
trigger a lookahead scan to satisfy block allocation requests -- which
will block the current thread for the duration of the lookahead scan.
But this seems to be more a problem of LFS_T_LOOKAHEAD interacting with
other traversals poorly.
Fortunately, long term, the current plan is to replace the lookahead
buffer with an on-disk block map on disks where the lookahead scan is a
bottleneck. If this gets implemented the problem goes away.
So re-reverting this for now. Worst case we can always re-re-revert this
again in the future. There is already a working implementation, so might
as well see where it goes...
Supporting incremental LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT does add a bit of a code
cost, but there is still some room for deduplicating lfsr_mtree_gc +
lfsr_fs_mkconsistent, which may be interesting:
code stack
before: 35232 2680
after: 35480 (+0.7%) 2680 (+0.0%)
Checking for orphans + other traversal work turned out to mesh much
worse than originally thought:
- Adjusting mids and being able to drop mdirs mid-traversal complicates
traversal quite a bit and has potential to hide difficult to reproduce
bugs.
- Implementing incremental mkconsistent requires it's own separate state
to detect mutation correctly since LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT and
LFS_T_LOOKAHEAD are invalidated by slightly different things.
- If hasorphans=true, we're likely going to find orphans and clobber the
traversal. So it's not really worth trying to opportunistically prove
there are no orphans while doing other traversal operations.
- We don't really want to traverse the mroot/mtree during mkconsistent,
which makes deduplicating these two functions a bit tricky. Doable,
but annoying.
- grms don't involve traversals and are their own separate awkward step
already.
Combine this with the fact that needing to scan for orphans should be
relatively rare in practice -- requiring either a powerloss or a
complicated set of file operations with at minimum 3 desynced files --
and parallel orphan checking starts to look like more trouble than it's
worth...
Instead, we now only check if the hasorphan bit has been set, and if it
has been we just call lfsr_fs_mkconsistent directly. This does a full
traversal in a single step, but at least makes it so traversal +
LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT in a background thread will do any necessary
janitorial work.
This saves a bit code:
code stack
before: 35480 2680
after: 35232 (-0.7%) 2680 (+0.0%)
What seemed like a simple tweak to lfsr_fs_fixorphans, integration into
lfsr_mtree_gc, turned out to be surprisingly annoying.
- We need an additional traversal flag, LFS_F_MUTATED, in order to know
if we intentionally modified the filesystem. This is different from
LFS_F_DIRTY in that we don't invalidate orphan scans:
- LFS_F_DIRTY => invalidate lookahead + orphans
- LFS_F_MUTATED => invalidate lookahead
- We need to break up lfsr_fs_fixorphans to expose lfsr_mdir_fixorphans,
which is probably a good thing for readability.
The interactions with each mdir being associated with a given mid is
not great though, and requires a bit of awkward mid shuffling.
- Unlike LFS_T_COMPACT, LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT introduces more complicated
mid changes, and makes it so mdirs can now be dropped in the middle of
traversal.
This messes with our internal lfsr_mtree_traverse -> lfsr_mtree_gc
control flow, and means a single lfsr_traversal_read call may process
an unbounded number of blocks in rare cases with lots of orphans.
But the good news is things are working, and lfsr_traversal_read with
LFS_T_MKCONSISTENT can scan for orphans in parallel with other traversal
operations.
Adds a bit of code:
code stack
before: 35220 2680
after: 35472 (+0.7%) 2680 (+0.0%)
The tests highlighted that the LFS_I_DIRTY flag in lfsr_tinfo approach
is insufficient. Consider what happens if our filesystem is mutated
while traversing the last mdir:
1. Traversal traverses last mdir, populate blocks, return first block
2. Filesystem mutated, maybe mdir was compacted, clobbers traversal and
sets LFS_I_DIRTY
3. Traversal return LFS_ERR_NOENT immediately, last block never
returned (and out of date), LFS_I_DIRTY never returned
Not only do we miss the LFS_I_DIRTY flag, but we completely miss the
last block in the mdir pair without any warning.
This is _not_ a problem for the actual lookahead buffer, since we still
internally check the LFS_I_DIRTY flag before marking it as complete, but
it is an issue for any external logic that depends on the traversal
being complete...
---
We could revert to LFS_T_EXCL, but, to be honest, I just really don't
know a good name for this flag...
LFS_T_EXCL is a bad name because it conflicts with LFS_O_EXCL. These
flags have very different behaviors, which risks confusing users, and
risks potential name conflicts down the line if we ever want
LFS_T_EXCL-esque semantics for open dirs/files (not unreasonable, though
quite fancy).
My current best contender is LFS_T_WATCH, but while scratching my head
on this, I starting to wonder why we're even providing LFS_T_EXCL in the
first place...
We err on the side of forcing users to implement filesystem-external
features themselves when possible elsewhere, and LFS_T_EXCL technically
_can_ be implemented entirely outside of the filesystem. Though to be
fair it is quite annoying/tedious.
It's not like there's any equivalent feature for dir/file reads anyways.
And a background thread calling lfsr_traversal_read with LFS_T_LOOKAHEAD
will still _eventually_ make progress, even if it takes a bit longer.
Don't get me wrong, I understand it is significantly easier to implement
this inside the filesystem than outside. But it's also easier to
implement this later than right now. And if we implement this later,
hopefully we'll have a better idea what exactly will be useful for
users.
---
Removing LFS_T_EXCL/LFS_I_DIRTY has no real impact on code cost. We were
really just exposing internal logic that we need for lookahead
correctness anyways:
code stack
before: 35224 2680
after: 35220 (-0.0%) 2680 (+0.0%)
This just forwards the internal LFS_I_DIRTY flag to the user via the
lfsr_tinfo flags field.
Benefits of this approach:
- Gives the user more flexibility on what to do if the filesystem is
modified, maybe you want to keep traversing depending on some other
logic.
- Can eventually add other flags to tinfo.flags, such as
LFS_I_COMPACTED, LFS_I_REPAIRED, LFS_I_INCONSISTENT, etc.
- Avoids confusion around the very different behaviors of LFS_O_EXCL and
LFS_T_EXCL.
I tried to come up with a better name (maybe LFS_T_WATCH?) but it was
a bit of a struggle... Switching to a flags approach sidesteps the
issue.
- Can drop the LFS_ERR_BUSY error code for now.
Code changes were fairly insignificant:
code stack
before: 35244 2680
after: 35224 (-0.1%) 2680 (+0.0%)
The only concern is that the tests highlighted it's possible for our
flag scheme to miss mutation if it happens after/during the last set of
blocks... Not sure how to handle this yet...
LFS_O_SYNC always implies LFS_O_FLUSH, otherwise what exactly are you
syncing? Making this explicit in the bit pattern should hopefully make
this clear for curious users, though lfsr_file_flush would be called
anyways because of how lfsr_file_sync is implemented.
This also moves the LFS_O_DESYNC bit pattern around so SYNC/FLUSH are
neighbors. SYNC/DESYNC may seem related, but in lfsr_file_open they
actually are quite different:
LFS_O_FLUSH 0x0040 ---- ---- -1-- ----
LFS_O_SYNC 0x00c0 ---- ---- 11-- ----
LFS_O_DESYNC 0x0100 ---- ---1 ---- ----
Code changes, mostly just noise from moving bits around:
code stack
before: 35228 2680
after: 35244 (+0.0%) 2680 (+0.0%)
It still doesn't make sense to check data without checking metadata, but
keeping this named LFS_T_CKDATA should hopefully clarify what it does
differently from LFS_T_CKMETA.
This implication is also now encoded in the bit pattern:
LFS_T_CKMETA 0x0100 ---- ---1 ---- ----
LFS_T_CKDATA 0x0300 ---- --11 ---- ----
In theory a clever user could force only the CKDATA bit to be set, and
such a configuration would _probably_ work fine, but it won't be
supported just to cut down on possible configurations to test.
No code changes:
code stack
before: 35228 2680
after: 35228 (+0.0%) 2680 (+0.0%)
It's probably a bad reason, but this avoids wasting too much time
figuring out how to name things.
Now most traversal functions return an lfsr_tag_t + lfsr_bptr_t pair,
which is enough to describe the current relevant traversal objects:
tag=LFSR_TAG_MDIR => (lfsr_mdir_t*)bptr.data.u.buffer
tag=LFSR_TAG_BRANCH => (lfsr_rbyd_t*)bptr.data.u.buffer
tag=LFSR_TAG_DATA => bptr.data
tag=LFSR_TAG_BPTR => bptr
This would be a bit better if lfsr_data_t's buffer field was a void*,
but that would mess with byte-level arithmetic, which is more common
with lfsr_data_ts.
This also adopts the fragmented/optional out-params used elsewhere in
the codebase. I thought this would add quite a bit more stack cost,
since we need redundant tags/bptrs to make lfsr_mtree_traverse/
lfsr_mtree_gc work, but surprisingly not:
code stack
before: 35256 2680
after: 35228 (-0.1%) 2680 (+0.0%)
It seems we make up the extra stack cost of redundant tags/bptrs by
giving the compiler more stack-alloc flexibility, tighter per-function
return types, and opting-out of tags/bptrs in most low-level traversals:
lfs_alloc mainly.
But if the fragmented/optional out-params is net harmful for code/stack
size, we should reconsider the pattern system-wide. This does probably
deserve a second look in the future...
This could go either way, it's a case of the classic C strchr type
conundrum.
But unlike iteration, we're more likely to mutate things when doing a
full traversal, so requiring everything to be mutable makes a bit more
sense.
Note that even readonly operations, fetchck for example, need access to
a mutable rbyd struct.
No code changes:
code stack
before: 35256 2680
after: 35256 (+0.0%) 2680 (+0.0%)
Just in case any tags leak through. If an orphan tag ended up in an
lfsr_stat call, it could be quite confusing to users...
Current types:
// user facing
LFS_TYPE_REG 1 ---1
LFS_TYPE_DIR 2 --1-
LFS_TYPE_SYMLINK* 3 --11
// internal
LFS_TYPE_BOOKMARK 4 -1-- -.
LFS_TYPE_ORPHAN 5 -1-1 +- on-disk only
LFS_TYPE_COMPR* 6 -11- -'
LFS_TYPE_TRAVERSAL 9 1--1 <-- in-ram only
* Hypothetical
This has no impact on code size:
code stack
before: 35228 2688
after: 35228 (+0.0%) 2688 (+0.0%)
So now files and traversals contain several nested structs:
file <-- lfsr_file_t
file.o <-- lfsr_obshrub_t
file.o.o <-- lfsr_omdir_t
This gets a bit ugly, but it's really the only way to make the compiler
happy when also with C's annoying strict aliasing rules.
This also makes lfsr_traversal_t a simple alias of lfsr_mtraversal_t,
with lfsr_mtraversal_t now including all of the obshrub/omdir state.
This simplifies things internally, and allows lfsr_mtree_gc to assert on
opened-list enrollment, but risks increased stack cost for all of the
unused fields.
Fortunately this stack cost turned out to not be that significant:
code stack
before: 35264 2680 (+0.0%)
after: 35256 (-0.0%) 2688 (+0.3%)
This adds an indirect pointer to lfsr_btraversal_t, so references to the
btree/bshrub root point to the actual btree/bshrub root rbyd struct.
This means if our bshrub root is mutated due to, say, mdir compaction,
this doesn't necessarily invalidate our btraversal.
But note this is strictly limited to bshrub roots. If you modify any
other part of the bshrub/btree, expect the traversal to be broken.
This means we can do whatever we want with mdirs and not worry about
invaliding bshrub traversals, which is quite nice! It also fixes our
failing bshrub-traversal-mutation tests.
This adds a bit of stack cost, but because we are moving fewer rbyd
structs around in lfsr_btree_traverse_, actually ends up saving a bit of
code. Though we are well below the compiler noise floor:
code stack
before: 35368 2680
after: 35356 (-0.0%) 2688 (+0.3%)
These aren't really different than btree nodes, except bshrubs need to
be enrolled in our opened list for commits to work.
Fortunately this is already true for explicit traversals, which are
currently the only traversals where we need to simultaneously mutate the
filesystem. This mainly just required adding additional checks for
LFS_TYPE_TRAVERSAL bshrubs, tests, and making sure traversal.bshrub is
never in an invalid state.
This continues to add code/stack cost for what is ultimately a
relatively niche feature:
code stack
before: 35268 2776
after: 35448 (+0.5%) 2800 (+0.9%)
Maybe btree/bshrub compactions should be disabled by default?
lfs_fs_gc is still not reimplemented, but this is accessible through the
traversal API with LFS_T_COMPACT.
This is also the first traversal operation that can mutate the
filesystem, which brings its own set of problems:
- We need to set LFS_F_DIRTY in lfsr_mtree_gc now, which really
highlights how much of a mess having two flag fields is...
We do _not_ clobber in this case, since we assume lfsr_mtree_gc knows
what it's doing.
- We can now commit to an mroot in the mroot chain outside of the normal
mroot chain update logic.
This is a bit scary, but should just work.
The only issue so far is that we need to allow mdirs to follow the
mroot during mroot splits if mid=-1, even if they aren't lfs_t's mroot
mdir.
This should now be decently tested with the new
test_traversal_compact_* tests.
- It's easy for mtraversal's mdir and mtinfo's mdir to fall out of sync
when mutating... Why do we have two of these?
The actual compaction itself is pretty straightforward: just mark as
unerased, eoff=-1, and call lfsr_mdir_commit with an empty commit. This
is now wrapped up in lfsr_mdir_compact.
Code changes:
code stack
before: 34528 2640
after: 34652 (+0.4%) 2640 (+0.0%)
Though the real hard part will be implementing gc_compact_thresh over
btree nodes...
It really doesn't make sense to check data and not check metadata. We're
already traversing the metadata, so validating it adds very little
overhead, and how can we trust our data if we can't trust our metadata?
This renames LFS_T_CKDATA -> LFS_T_CK, which now also implies
LFS_T_CKMETA. This implication is done explicitly in lfsr_mtree_traverse
instead of doing anything fancy with flags.
Implying LFS_T_CKMETA also means one less configuration to support.
Code changes:
code stack
before: 34524 2640
after: 34528 (+0.0%) 2640 (+0.0%)
Separated out omdir/mdir and mtraversal. You still need to allocate an
mdir for mtraversal to work, but this avoids the extra cost of omdir's
linked-list.
To avoid _too_ many pointers, I duplicated the flags field into both
lfsr_traversal_t and lfsr_mtraversal_t. This is basically free since we
end up with a bunch of padding for mtraversal's state field, but comes
with the risk of getting confused when the two flag fields don't match
in the future.
I also merged the intermediary btype field into flags to avoid yet
another single-byte field, where it fits comfortably in 3-bits.
Note that the mdir can be uninitialized in cases where we don't need to
worry about traversal clobbering.
---
This has the same problems as separating out mdirs/bshrubs in bshrub
functions: more stack/code to move the multiple pointers around, but is
necessary to avoid strict aliasing issues. There's no way to represent
overlapping omdir/mdir/mtraversal struct in standard C99 otherwise.
The end result saves a bit of code, but adds a bit of stack:
code stack
before: 34576 2632
after: 34524 (-0.2%) 2640 (+0.3%)
Though these numbers may be close enough to the compiler noise floor to
not really care about...
This gets a bit messy, since lfsr_bshrub_commit really requires the
bshrub to be enrolled in the opened mdir list to stage correctly.
To make this work, our internal SHRUBCOMMIT and SHRUBTRUNK attrs now
take a pointer to the active shrub, and assume it is followed by a
staging shrub in memory. This is a big hack/assumption that leaks
through lfsr_bshrub_commit, but it at gets the job done in our current
system.
Note some functions were renamed instead, these didn't really make sense
as pure-bshrub functions:
- lfsr_bshrub_readnext -> lfsr_file_readnext
- lfsr_bshrub_read -> lfsr_file_read_
---
The main reason for this is to comply with C99's strict aliasing rules,
which can be a real PIA sometimes.
We need to track a bshrub in lfsr_mtraversal_t, but we really don't want
to pay the RAM cost for an entire lfsr_file_t. The best option I've
found is to pass around multiple pointers to the relevant internal
structs (mdir+bshrub), but this adds a stack+code cost.
So far, strict aliasing is a net downside:
code stack
before: 34478 2624
-fno-strict-aliasing: 34502 (+0.1%) 2616 (-0.3%)
after: 34566 (+0.3%) 2632 (+0.3%)
But it's baked into the standard and we can't always rely on
-fno-strict-aliasing being available.
Been leaning towards this naming scheme. Now lfsr_omdir_* functions
match the lfsr_omdir_t type they operate on.
- Renamed lfs.opened -> lfs.omdirs
- Renamed lfsr_opened_isopen -> lfsr_omdir_isopen
- Renamed lfsr_opened_add -> lfsr_omdir_open
- Renamed lfsr_opened_remove -> lfsr_omdir_close
- Renamed lfsr_mid_isopen -> lfsr_omdir_ismidopen
So now lfsr_traversal_read will only return LFS_ERR_BUSY if LFS_T_EXCL
was provided to lfsr_traversal_open.
This means it's no longer possible to opportunistically traverse blocks,
_and_ detect mutation in the same traversal (though I suppose you could
open multiple traversals for this?), but on the flipside this
potentially frees up the implementation a bit.
This motivation for this is that LFS_ERR_BUSY is potentially confusing
and annoying to handle if you don't care about mutation.
code stack
before: 34566 2624
after: 34558 (-0.0%) 2624 (+0.0%)
This splits LFSR_TSTATE_BTREE into separate LFSR_TSTATE_MTREE/BTREE/
OBTREE states that indicate what to do next after traversing the btree.
This removes the need to point indirectly to file's o.next pointer,
since we can just point to the file struct itself.
I've also simplified opened-file clobbering to just move to the next
opened mdir, instead of searching for another unsynced file. This
simplifies things but does mean we now need to clobber traversals when
closing non-file objects. Implicitly calling lfsr_opened_clobber in
lfsr_opened_remove solves this with very little extra code cost,
deduplicated, and gives us a stronger invariant for traversal references
to closed objects. So win win?
Oh, and all the explicit open-file clobber checks are now deduplicated
into lfsr_opened_clobber again.
These tweaks save quite a bit of code:
code stack
before: 34740 2624
after: 34570 (-0.5%) 2624 (+0.0%)
Now, lfsr_mdir_commit just clobbers all traversals associated with the
current mdir, irrespective of mid.
This makes our traversal clobbering model quite a bit simpler, drops any
mess related to bshrub staging, and allows lfsr_mdir_commit to handle
most of the clobbering logic with the exception of opened file handles.
This also fits mtree/mroot clobbering a bit better, with mtree
clobbering behaving the same as a file btree in the mroot.
The downside is we will miss more blocks during clobbered traversals,
but clobbered traversals are best effort anyways. The saved code cost
and simpler/more robust clobbering model are probably worth it.
Traversal clobbering is already complicated enough...
Code/stack changes:
code stack
before: 34716 2648
after: 34740 (+0.1%) 2624 (-0.9%)
A number of traversal changes:
- Traversal now traverses the mtree's btree (the inner btree nodes)
separately from iterating over mdirs in the mtree.
This makes resuming clobbered traversals more robust as there's less
state to worry about. It also reduces all btree traversals to a single
state which simplifies the traversal logic and _in theory_ reduces
code/RAM costs.
This does add a second O(n logbn) pass through the mtree, but this
takes the fast path since we already validated btree nodes. mtree
traversal is probably dominated by mdir fetching anyways...
- lfsr_mdir_commit no longer clobbers mid-related traversals. This was a
bit too complicated with attrs potentially inserting new mids.
Instead, it's up to upper layers to explicitly clobber traversals.
Most of these already need to update dir positions, so it's not that
much extra code, but it does add cost.
lfsr_mdir_commit still clobbers mroot/mtree related traversals.
- We now stage bshrubs in traversals during mdir compaction, so we
shouldn't need to clobber traversals when the mdir compacts.
In theory as long as we clobber traversals that reference opened
files, we should never end up being the only reference to a bshrub. So
we should be able to stage bshrubs without cost.
This is _not_ working at the moment, because we aren't updating the
actual btraversal state correctly... not sure how to fix this yet...
Code/stack changes:
code stack
before: 34682 2544
after: 34716 (+0.1%) 2648 (+4.1%)
The surprise stack cost is _very_ interesting. Where is this coming
from?
It turns out when we reduce all btree traversals to a single state, and a
single function call, GCC is happy to inline lfsr_btree_traverse
directly into lfsr_fs_traverse.
This is great for code cost, but now lfs_fs_traverse contains the entire
stack frame of lfsr_btree_traverse, which is quite large. When we called
lfsr_btree_traverse twice, this stack frame was never nested with
lfsr_mtree_lookup, but now our tools think it is...
I'm not sure how to fix this. Maybe improving our tooling to understand
shrinkwrap optimizations will find this doesn't actually cost as much?
Or maybe not since this is in a complicated switch case state machine?
We could use an explicit __attribute__((noinline)), but this sort of
heavy-handed optimization guidance has been out-of-scope for littlefs up
until now...
I'm leaving this as-is for now, but it may be worth looking this again
in the future.
This adds lfsr_opened_clobber which can be called to clobber any open
traversals related to an mid, or all traversals if mid=-1. Clobbering
here means throw away any in-progress btraversals and move to the next
mid. We need to do this in several places to avoid outdated references
to btrees.
The other option would be to treat traversals like additional unsynced
file handles, add them to the lookahead buffer, copy shrubs during
compaction, etc, but I don't think we want to pay this cost since the
underlying data is otherwise inaccessible. No reason to check/repair
blocks we're not using anymore...
To make this work, LFS_BTRAVERSAL(bid) now supports resuming from a
specific bid, in lfsr_mtraversal_t we use this to resume mtree traversal
from a specific mid when clobbered.
---
Other changes:
- lfsr_mdir_commit now marks all removed mdirs with LFS_F_ZOMBIE, and
updating related dir positions is done in lfsr_remove/lfsr_rename.
I was originally planning to use LFS_F_ZOMBIE to clobber traversals as
well, but it didn't work out.
- Added lfsr_fs_weight, which returns the effective mdir/mtree weight,
including inlined-in-mroot mdirs.
- Fixed did-mask miscalculation in lfsr_mkdir where fs/mtree weight
wasn't shifted by mdir_bits. This probably just went unnoticed during
some mid refactoring.
- Changed traversals to only traverse _unsynced_ opened files. No reason
to traverse files we know match disk. This also makes is so only
unsynced files need to worry about clobbering traversals.
This has the catch that we need to point to the traversing file handle
somehow so we can clobber correctly. The (hacky?) solution is to point
to the next pointer itself, which tells us both where to go next, and
what file handle we are currently traversing.
- Moved LFS_F_UNSYNC flags to before file operations, instead of after.
This is needed for the above traverse-unsync-only logic in case we
alloc in the middle of a file operation.
Code changes:
code stack
before: 34454 2544
after: 34682 (+0.7%) 2544 (+0.0%)
Also added some specific tests over corner cases caused by traversing
and mutating the filesystem at the same time.
Unfortunately these aren't passing yet. Our mid-clobbering logic doesn't
handle mid insertion correctly, so we end up clobbering more traversals
than we need to...
This sort of turned into a complete refactor of lfs_alloc in order to
move/reuse the lookahead buffer filling logic into lfsr_fs_traverse.
lfs_alloc now calls lfsr_fs_traverse to fill the lookahead buffer when
no more blocks are available, but also you can too with lfsr_traversal_t
+ LFS_T_LOOKAHEAD.
The one big caveat being if any mutation happens to the filesystem, any
incomplete lookahead needs to be tossed out. To help with this,
lfsr_traversal_read now returns LFS_ERR_BUSY (-16) instead of
LFS_ERR_NOENT (-2) if the filesystem has been modified since the
traversal was opened.
Note that by default lfsr_traversal_t will still try to keep traversing
blocks, but can be told to terminate immediately with LFS_T_EXCL.
Continuing the traversal is probably desired for checking checksums,
debugging, etc, as otherwise you could end up looping over only the
first couple blocks in a write-heavy system, but if you are trying to
populate the lookahead buffer you probably want to just abort and start
over.
I considered adding a flags field to lfs_tinfo for this, but decided
against it since it would be the only place in the current API where we
don't use error codes to convey behavior-changing information. Though
this may be worth reconsidering at some point...
---
In reworking lfs_alloc, a lot of the internal logic was broken up into
specific functions:
- lfs_alloc_ckpoint - checkpoint the allocator
- lfs_alloc_discard - discard any lookahead
- lfs_alloc_shift - discard/shift lookahead if progress can be made
- lfs_alloc_markinuse - mark a block as in-use
- lfs_alloc_markfree - mark any remaining blocks as free
- lfs_alloc_findnext - find the next free block in lookahead
If anything this probably makes lfs_alloc more readable, though the
original motivation was to allow lfsr_traversal_t to only shift/zero the
lookahead buffer if there's a chance we can make progress.
This was based on upstream work by opilat and myself.
Code changes:
code stack
before: 34226 2560
after: 34474 (+0.7%) 2552 (-0.3%)
This adds the lfsr_traversal_t object, which encapsulates a traversal
over all blocks in the filesystem.
This replaces the earlier lfs_fs_traverse function, but is sort of
"inside-out" in that instead of taking a callback, an lfsr_traversal_t
object can be read from to return lfs_tinfo structs that describe the
blocks in our system:
lfsr_traversal_open(&lfs, &t) => 0;
lfsr_traversal_read(&lfs, &t, &tinfo) => 0;
tinfo.btype => LFS_BTYPE_MDIR;
tinfo.block => 0x0;
lfsr_traversal_read(&lfs, &t, &tinfo) => 0;
tinfo.btype => LFS_BTYPE_MDIR;
tinfo.block => 0x1;
lfsr_traversal_read(&lfs, &t, &tinfo) => 0;
tinfo.btype => LFS_BTYPE_DATA;
tinfo.block => 0x42;
lfsr_traversal_read(&lfs, &t, &tinfo) => LFS_ERR_NOENT;
lfsr_traversal_close(&lfs, &t) => 0;
This is more flexible, allowing for aborted traversals, yielding,
rewinding, etc, but also more complicated to implement, since it
requires all traversal state to be stored explicitly.
Fortunately, since we needed to reimplement filesystem traversals
anyways, I was able to build this into the new system from the start
using a small state machine to drive the traversal internally. So all
that was really needed was a bit of window dressing, adding
LFS_TYPE_TRAVERSAL to track open traversals, logic to handle
invalidating traversals on file close, mutation, etc...
Which, uh, that last one is not implemented yet. Interactions with other
filesystem operations gets messy, so I figured I'd go ahead and commit
what is currently working.
Ugh, and tests. The biggest downside of adding lfsr_traversal_t is how
many more corner-cases it adds to the system...
lfsr_traversal_t is going to be a work-in-progress for a bit...
---
lfsr_traversal_t also adds a really interesting path towards more access
to advanced low-level operations, such as checking metadata/data
checksums, incrementally progressing the garbage collector, even
repairing bad metadata/data blocks eventually.
Currently implemented is LFS_T_CKMETADATA and LFS_T_CKDATA to check
metadata and data checksums respectively. This is the first feature that
actually allows you to validate data checksums.
Code changes so far:
code stack
before: 33886 2560
after: 34226 (+1.0%) 2560 (+0.0%)
With rcompat/wcompat flags, on-disk minor version bumps will hopefully
not be needed for a long time (ever?). And if the on-disk version never
changes, why was a word to report it every lfsr_fs_stat call?
But this may be something to listen to user feedback on. Worst case we
can always readd fsinfo.disk_version if users find it useful.
Code changes:
code stack
before: 33922 2592
after: 33918 (-0.0%) 2592 (+0.0%)
Well this turned into a never-ending can of worms...
I guess the good news is our newly added lfsr_grow_incr_* tests are
_very_ good at finding post-error-resume bugs.
Implementation-wise, this was fairly straightforward thanks to prior
work by BrianPugh, kaetemi, and myself:
1. Made block_count pseudo-optional by adding lfs.block_count so we can
mutate it based on what we find on-disk.
This was done a bit different from the previous implementation,
instead of setting block_count=0 to read the block_count from disk,
we allow any block_count <= the configured block_count.
This matches how we handle name_limit/file_limit/etc, and allows
users to mount a filesystem with unknown block_count while asserting
an upper bound.
2. Added lfsr_fs_grow, which can grow the filesystem.
The is basically the same as the previous implementation except we're
a bit more careful with the lookahead buffer.
I thought the previous impl might have been broken w.r.t. lookahead
buffer, but fortunately it's only broken in a way that makes us think
newly available blocks are temporarily in-use. Which is a bit funny.
One interesting thing that came out with more aggressive tests is
that it's possible to get locked-up in lfsr_fs_preparemutation trying
to clean up grms/orphans before we change the filesystem size.
Fortunately it turns out we don't _really_ need to call
lfsr_fs_preparemutation here. This gets a bit delicate, but means we
should always be able to grow a full filesystem.
To test this I've added both the simple grow/error tests from the
previous version, as well as a set of fuzz tests (a la test_relocations
and friends) that incrementally grow the filesystem when encountering
LFS_ERR_NOSPC. These have a surprising amount coverage, testing
lfsr_fs_grow, lfsr_fs_stat, lfsr_fs_size, and resuming operations after
encountering an error.
Which also means they found bugs:
- lfs_alloc_setinuse was not broken before, because lookahead.start was
always a multiple of lookahead_size. But now with lfs_alloc_discard,
this invariant may not be true.
I've just changed all lookahead.start updates to mod block_count. This
adds a bit of code, but is much easier to reason about.
While fixing this, I also added an assert to never allocate blocks
{0,1} in lfs_alloc. This is a good assert to have, but did require
some tweaks to test_btree to avoid these blocks.
- We were incorrectly patching grms in lfsr_mdir_commit when mdelta=0.
Funnily enough we also proceed to ignore the patched grm most of the
time when mdelta=0, so this went unnoticed.
- It turns out we're completely ignoring rid=-1 attrs if we split the
mroot. Not sure how this was missed. It's a bit important.
Note this is still broken. Fixing this requires some rather invasive
changes to lfsr_mdir_commit's internal logic that should probably be
in another commit...
Note again fwrite_fuzz is omitted. Currently the state of data in opened
files is undefined after a failed write, so this wouldn't really be
testing anything interesting...
More features = more code, and all of this bug fixing meant several
things contributed to code/stack changes in this commit:
code stack
before: 33654 2592
+variable block_count: 33646 (-0.0%) 2584 (+0.0%)
+lfsr_fs_grow: 33818 (+0.5%) 2584 (-0.3%)
+lookahead-start-fix: 33842 (+0.6%) 2584 (-0.3%)
+grm-patch-fix (after): 33850 (+0.6%) 2584 (-0.3%)
Wild that variable block_count actually saves code/stack. I guess the
indirect lfs->cfg->block_count load can get costly...
The idea behind LFS_ERR_UNKNOWN is to reserve -1 as a general purpose
"Idunno what error code to use just bail" error. Discouraged for
production code, but very useful for hacking things together either for
quick prototypes or when trying to bootstrap a system.
-1 was actually already carved out for this purpose, but not documented.
I've used it heavily in other project, and it would be good to actually
codify this so others know the option is available.
This should end up being one of the allowed bd error codes, along with
LFS_ERR_IO, LFS_ERR_CORRUPT, etc.
---
If you try to map this to Linux errno codes, this does unfortunately
conflict with EPERM (-1), but what is EPERM other than an arbitrary "you
can't do that" error? Outside of Linux/POSIX, I think you can probably
get away with using EACCES (-13) for permission related errors instead.
I think the tradeoff is well worth it given we're not _really_
constrained to exact POSIX semantics.
Returning the actual on-disk file type is probably more useful for users
as this gives them more information.
I was originally concerned about collisions with future internal types,
LFS_TYPE_TRAVERSAL, etc, needed for internal opened-list tracking, but
it turns out we can avoid problems by starting internal types at 0x80,
since on-disk file types are only 7-bits.
Code changes:
code stack
before: 33710 2592
after: 33694 (-0.0%) 2592 (+0.0%)
This adds a couple things so our unknown file types don't just cause our
filesystem to fall over:
- lfsr_mount now prints a warning on any unknown file types found at
mount time. Since we're already iterating over all files to find
orphans, this is basically free.
- Added LFS_TYPE_UNKNOWN to represent files with an unknown/unsupported
type. This is now returned by lfsr_stat/lfsr_dir_read for files of any
unknow type.
- Added LFS_ERR_NOTSUP. This is now returned by functions that attempt
to modify a file of unknown type, and my have more use cases in the
future.
It's tempting to allow remove/rename on unknown file types, but since
we don't know what data structures these may be referencing, doing so
would likely leak storage. Or worse. Shrubs for example would just
explode if you only moved the metadata entry.
This also adds test_incompat_unknown to test these cases.
Code changes are minimal, though there are a number of extra conditions
to check for unknown file types. The lfsr_mount condition is
particularly fun as it should be completely optimized out when debug
statements are disabled:
code stack
before: 33670 2592
after: 33710 (+0.1%) 2592 (+0.0%)
test_compat has been very useful for testing compatibility on patch and
minor releases.
Though, in porting the tests, I've realized these are actually really
flimsy w.r.t. API changes... lfsp_config notably relies on compatible
struct layouts, which is _not_ guaranteed by littlefs's compatibility
rules.
For this reason I've restricted these tests to only run if LFS_VERSION
doesn't change, though this may be worth reinvestigating in the future.
test_compat on minor API releases would be quite valuable...
lfsr_fs_stat is also not quite up to date with upstream yet. It's really
just a small shim copying over static configs at the moment (except for
name_limit/file_limit). This is because we're still missing most of what
would actually be interesting here: variable block counts, minor
versions, etc.
And of course a minimal lfsr_fs_stat means minimal code changes:
code stack
before: 33642 2592
after: 33670 (+0.1%) 2592 (+0.0%)
See comments/previous commits. lfsr_fs_mkconsistent allows running
internal consistency operations without any other filesystem changes.
Implementation-wize, this just calls lfsr_fs_preparemutation which we
already need to, uh, prepare for mutation. Though it may do some
additional work in the future, such as setting compat flags, version
numbers, etc.
Added mkconsistent permutations to what seems like the relevant tests:
- test_forphans - easy for lfsr_fs_mkconsistent to accidentally delete
orphans/zombies.
- test_powerloss - heavy fuzz tests over powerloss-related consistency
operations, though this does multiply every permutation by ~2x...
Code cost minimal. I guess this is what it costs to make an internal
function non-static:
code stack
before: 33634 2592
after: 33642 (+0.0%) 2592 (+0.0%)
The previous cksum + parity scheme worked, but needing to calculate both
cksum + parity on slightly different sets of metadata felt overly
complicated. After taking a step back, I've realized the problem is that
we're trying to force perturb effects to be implicit via the parity. If we
instead actually implement perturb effects explicitly, things get quite
a bit simpler...
This does add a bit more logic to the read path, but I don't think it's
worse than the mess we needed to parse separate cksum + parity.
Now, the perturb bit has the explicit behavior of inverting all tag
valid bits in the following commit. Which is conveniently the same as
xoring the crc32c with 00000080 before parsing each tag:
.---+---+---+---. . . .---+---+---+---. \ \ \ \
|v| tag | |v| tag | | | | |
+---+---+---+---+ +---+---+---+---+ | | | |
| commit | | commit | | | | |
| | | | +-. | | |
+---+---+---+---+ +---+---+---+---+ / | | | |
|v|p--------------. |v|p| tag | | . . .
+---+---+---+---+ | +---+---+---+---+ | . . .
| cksum | | | cksum | | . . .
+---+---+---+---+ | +---+---+---+---+ | . . .
| padding | | | padding | | . . .
| | | | | | . . .
+---+---+---+---+ | . +---+---+---+---+ | | | |
| erased | +-> |v------------------' | | |
| | | +---+---+---+---+ | | |
. . | | commit | +-. | +- rbyd
. . | | | | | | | cksum
| +---+---+---+---+ / | +-. /
'-> |v----------------------' | |
+---+---+---+---+ / |
| cksum ----------------'
+---+---+---+---+
| padding |
| |
+---+---+---+---+
| erased |
| |
. .
. .
With this scheme, we don't need to calculate a separate parity, because
each valid bit effectively validates the current state of the perturb
bit.
We also don't need extra logic to omit valid bits from the cksum,
because flipping all valid bits effectively makes perturb=0 the
canonical metadata encoding and cksum.
---
I also considered only inverting the first valid bit, which would have
the additional benefit of allowing entire commits to be crc32ced at
once, but since we don't actually track when we've started a commit
this turned out to be quite a bit more complicated than I thought.
We need someway to validate the first valid bit, otherwise it could be
flipped by a failed prog and we'd never notice. This is fine, we can
store a copy of the previous perturb bit in the next cksum tag, but it
does mean we need to track the perturb bit for the duration of the
commit. So we'd end up needing to track both start-of-commit and the
perturb bit state, which starts getting difficult to fit into our rbyd
struct...
It's easier and simpler to just flip every valid bit. As a plus this
means every valid bit contributes to validating the perturb bit.
---
Also renamed LFSR_TAG_PERTURB -> LFSR_TAG_NOISE just to avoid confusion.
Though not sure if this tag should stick around...
The end result is a nice bit of code/stack savings, which is what we'd
expect with a simpler scheme:
code stack
before: 33746 2600
after: 33570 (-0.5%) 2592 (-0.3%)
This sort of reverts the addition of lfsr_bd_unprog, but with a slightly
better API. lfsr_bd_unprog was too much of a hack, and isn't really
generalizable. The align flag isn't necessarily any better, but at least
it's the simplest/least-confusing solution available.
And it's net savings, code-wise:
code stack lfs_t
before: 33690 2608 164
after: 33678 (-0.0%) 2600 (-0.3%) 160 (-2.4%)
While exploring the test_badblocks ERASENOOP failure more, I realized
the problem is that we are nesting crc32cs.
To be clear, using crc32cs to validate progs in general is not an issue,
that is perfectly fine on paper. The issue is that we were using crc32cs
to validate progs _that contain crc32cs_.
Looking at the collision, we can see the fully expanded lleb128s we use
for our cksum tags:
00 00 00 ff b0 02 00 87 80 80 00 3e c0 7f 7e => bdfa9b10
ab 77 de c2 b0 03 00 87 80 80 00 3e 38 d5 22 => bdfa9b10
'-.-' ^ '----.----' '----.----'
'----|------|-----------|-- cksum tag
'------|-----------|-- cksum weight (0)
'-----------|-- cksum size + padding
'-- cksum crc32c
So we ended up perfectly aligning the cksum's crc32c with our cache
line. Lucky us.
Unfortunately funny math makes it so that whenever a crc32c contains a
crc32c, the inner crc32c sort of cancels itself out from the outer
crc32c. So these two messages end up mathematically equivalent, even
though they contain different data:
crc(m) = m(x) x^|P|-1 mod P
crc(m ++ crc(m)) = (m(x) x^|P|-1 + (m(x) x^|P|-1 mod P)) x^|P|-1 mod P
crc(m ++ crc(m)) = (m(x) x^|P|-1 + m(x) x^|P|-1) x^|P|-1 mod P
crc(m ++ crc(m)) = 0 x^|P|-1 mod P
crc(m ++ crc(m)) = 0
So using a crc32c to check progs is not fit for purpose.
This leaves us with a couple options:
1. Use a different checksum, or do something like rearranging bytes to
avoid this cancelling out issue. Unfortunately this gets tricky since
crc32cs are linear, simply using an xor mask won't work...
2. Don't check progs at such a low-level, but at a high-level using the
rbyd/data block crc32cs. Since this would mean only one crc32c, this
would avoid nesting issues. Unfortunately this would probably come
with quite a high code cost to try to keep track of both the
before+after rbyd cksums everywhere...
3. Just read back the data into the rcache to compare at the byte-level,
which would mean clobbering our rcache when prog checking is enabled.
This commit goes with option 3., which is probably the simplest. It also
removes any question of crc32c collision, which could be a real nuisance
when debugging low-level block device operations, a use case where prog
checking will hopefully be quite valuable.
Clobbering the rcache also has the advantage of reverting the prog
>= read requirement, which is nice for flexibility. Though this needs to
be tested.
---
There was a bit of a hiccup, and that was how prog checking interacts
with lfsr_bd_cpy. lfsr_bd_cpy used the rcache to hold data being copied
to/from disk, but this data needs to be checked, and prog checking would
clobber the rcache. Problems! I guess this is one footgun of the
internal lfsr_bd_readnext API...
The solution is to instead turn this around and use the pcache to hold
any copied data, since this would not be clobbered when prog checking.
This has some other knock-on effects, mainly that we can't take
advantage of read hints in lfsr_bd_cpy, but has the added advantage of
potentially not clobbering the rcache at all when no checking progs.
Code changes were fairly minimal:
code stack
before: 33718 2608
after: 33690 (-0.1%) 2608 (+0.0%)
This configuration option enables the previous behavior of reading back
every prog to check that the data was written correctly.
Unfortunately, this brings a bit of baggage, thanks to our cache
interactions being more complicated now:
- We really want to reuse the rcache for prog validation, despite the
cache performance implications. Unfortunately, we simply can't, thanks
to the new bd utility functions tying up the rcache. lfsr_bd_cpy, for
example, does not expect rcache to be invalidated between a read and
prog, and if it is, things break (I may or may not have found this by
experience).
These bd utilities are valuable, so we really need some other way to
validate our progs.
- Since we can't rely on the rcache, this leaves checksumming as the
only option for validating progs. Checksumming isn't perfect, as there
is a decent chance of false negatives, but to be honest it's probably
good enough for anything that's not malicious.
- This also adds the new constraint that we need to be able to read back
any prog into the pcache, which implies read_size <= prog_size. This
constraint didn't exist when we could clobber our rcache, but this is
not worth throwing away the new bd utilities. Not to mention
clobbering our rcache could hurt cache performance.
Why not make read_size <= prog_size conditional on check_progs?
The main reason is convenience. One very compelling use case for
check_progs is to help debug unknown filesystem/integration failures,
buf if you can't enable check_progs without changing the filesystem
configuration, you can't really rely on check_progs for debugging.
This helps future proof what we expect from block devices, in case
future error detection/correction mechanisms can benefit from our
prog_size always being readable.
Code changes were not that significant, however there was a surprising
stack cost. This seems to be because lfsr_bd_read__ can now be called
from multiple places, causing it to no longer be inlined in
lfsr_bd_read_, costing a bit of stack for the additional function call:
before: 33566 2624
after: 33682 (+0.3%) 2640 (+0.6%)
The mleafweight naming is... not great...
Renaming mleaf_bits -> mdir_bits and replacing mleafweight with explicit
shifts of 1 << mdir_bits seems to get the job done without introducing a
new and potentially confusing name.
This was a lesson learned from recycle_bits. Sometimes more helpers just
makes code less, not more, readable.
This makes a bit more sense with the new block_recycles name.
block_recycles=0 (previously block_recycles=1) requires 1 erase, but it
doesn't really "recycle" the block. With this change, block_recycles=1
"recycles" the block once (2 erases in total) before relocating, which I
think is a bit more intuitive.
Note, this sort of messes with our power-of-2 rounding, as the
block_recycles is technically rounded down to the nearest power-of-2
after adding 1:
- block_recycles=1022 -> 512 erases
- block_recycles=1023 -> 1024 erases
- block_recycles=1024 -> 1024 erases
- block_recycles=1025 -> 1024 erases
But I'm going to keep the block_recycles description more-or-less as is
for now, as I think this extra detail is more confusing than useful,
powers-of-2 stay powers-of-2, and the <=block_recycles contraint is not
violated.
The original goal here was to restore all of the revision count/
wear-leveling features that were intentionally ignored during
refactoring, but over time a few other ideas to better leverage our
revision count bits crept in, so this is sort of the amalgamation of
that...
Note! None of these changes affect reading. mdir fetch strictly needs
only to look at the revision count as a big 32-bit counter to determine
which block is the most recent.
The interesting thing about the original definition of the revision
count, a simple 32-bit counter, is that it actually only needs 2-bits to
work. Well, three states really: 1. most recent, 2. less recent, 3.
future most recent. This means the remaining bits are sort of up for
grabs to other things.
Previously, we've used the extra revision count bits as a heuristic for
wear-leveling. Here we reintroduce that, a bit more rigorously, while
also carving out space for a nonce to help with commit collisions.
Here's the new revision count breakdown:
vvvvrrrr rrrrrrnn nnnnnnnn nnnnnnnn
'-.''----.----''---------.--------'
'------|---------------|---------- 4-bit relocation revision
'---------------|---------- recycle-bits recycle counter
'---------- pseudorandom nonce
- 4-bit relocation revision
We technically only need 2-bits to tell which block is the most
recent, but I've bumped it up to 4-bits just to be safe and to make
it a bit more readable in hex form.
- recycle-bits recycle counter
A user configurable counter, this counter tracks how many times a
metadata block has been erased. When it overflows we return the block
to the allocator to participate in block-level wear-leveling again.
This implements our copy-on-bounded-write strategy.
- pseudorandom nonce
The remaining bits we fill with a pseudorandom nonce derived from the
filesystem's prng. Note this prng isn't the greatest (it's just the
xor of all mdir cksums), but it gets the job done. It should also be
reproducible, which can be a good thing.
Suggested by ithinuel, the addition of a nonce should help with the
commit collision issue caused by noop erases. It doesn't completely
solve things, since we're only using crc32c cksums not collision
resistant cryptographic hashes, but we still have the existing
valid/perturb bit system to fall back on.
When we allocate a new mdir, we want to zero the recycle counter. This
is where our relocation revision is useful for indicating which block is
the most recent:
initial state: 10101010 10101010 10101010 10101010
'-.'
+1 zero random
v .----'----..---------'--------.
lfsr_rev_init: 10110000 00000011 01110010 11101111
When we increment, we increment recycle counter and xor in a new nonce:
initial state: 10110000 00000011 01110010 11101111
'--------.----''---------.--------'
+1 xor <-- random
v v
lfsr_rev_init: 10110000 00000111 01010100 01000000
And when the recycle counter overflows, we relocate the mdir.
If we aren't wear-leveling, we just increment the relocation revision to
maximize the nonce.
---
Some other notes:
- Renamed block_cycles -> block_recycles.
This is intended to help avoid confusing block_cycles with the actual
physical number of erase cycles supported by the device.
I've noticed this happening a few times, and it's unfortunately
equivalent to disabling wear-leveling completely. This can be improved
with better documentation, but also changing the name doesn't hurt.
- We now relocate both blocks in the mdir at the same time.
Previously we only relocated one block in the mdir per recycle. This
was necessary to keep our threaded linked-list in sync, but the
threaded linked-list is now no more!
Relocating both blocks is simpler, updates the mtree less often,
compatible with metadata redundancy, and avoids aliasing issues that
were a problem when relocating one block.
Note that block_recycles is internally multiplied by 2 so each block
sees the correct number of erase cycles.
- block_recycles is now rounded down to a power-of-2.
This makes the counter logic easier to work with and takes up less RAM
in lfs_t. This is a rough heuristic anyways.
- Moved the lfs->seed updates into lfsr_mountinited + lfsr_mdir_commit.
This avoids readonly operations affecting the seed and should help
reproducibility.
- Changed rev count in dbg scripts to render as hex, similar to cksums.
Now that we using most of the bits in the revision count, the decimal
version is, uh, not helpful...
Code changes:
code stack
before: 33342 2640
after: 33434 (+0.3%) 2640 (+0.0%)
The main change is moving away from applying gstate changes via special
attrs. Instead, gstate changes are applied implicitly, whenever the
relevant field in lfs_t differs from the gstate on-disk.
How do we recover from errors then? Well, we already need to track the
exact on-disk encoding of any gstate (grm_p) to avoid issues with minor
encoding differences, so if we encounter an error, we can revert any
changes to gstate by re-decoding the on-disk gstate. This is more
fragile: 1. all error paths in lfsr_mdir_commit need to revert gstate,
2. logic must not error between gstate updates and lfsr_mdir_commit, but
it gets the job done.
The benefit of this approach is that it's much easier to manipulate
gstate inside of lfsr_mdir_commit. No more hacky attr-list scanning to
patch grms mid-commit! It also in theory saves stack usage by dropping
an attr, but none of these attrs were on our stack hot-path.
Other gstate changes:
- Moved all grm adjustments into lfsr_mdir_commit.
This should deduplicate the messy grm adjust logic and make grms
easier to work with.
One hiccup though is the temporarily self-removing bookmark created in
lfsr_mkdir, which needs to create a grm referencing an mid that
doesn't exist yet. To work around this, lfsr_mdir_commit now
automatically creates grms for new bookmarks.
This might be a problem if we ever elide same-mdir mkdirs, but if so
we can solve that problem then.
- Dropped lfsr_data_t xoring, the added complexity wasn't really worth
it since all gstate should be small enough to buffer on the stack.
- Renamed several things:
- lfsr_grm_push/poprm -> lfsr_grm_push/pop
- lfsr_grm_isrm -> lfsr_grm_ispending
- grm_g -> grm_p
- grm.rms -> grm.mids
- Moved things around so grm/gstate logic is grouped together.
Unfortunately none of these attrs were on our stack hot-path, so no
stack savings. But thanks to the simpler logic, this does save quite a
bit of code:
code stack
before: 33514 2632
after: 33338 (+0.5%) 2640 (+0.3%)
So for example:
file->m.mdir.mid => file->o.mdir.mid
We already use "o" in opened-list iterations, so this is a bit more
consistent. And it doesn't increase the already obnoxious
file->o.mdir.rbyd.blocks[0] field names...
Now that lfsr_dir_t contains a single lfsr_opened_t, it makes sense for
lfsr_opened_t to always come first in lfsr_dir_t/lfsr_file_t for
consistency.
This also allows cheaper lfsr_file_t <-> lfsr_opened_t casts (noops),
which saves a bit of code:
code stack
before: 33582 2632
after: 33538 (-0.1%) 2632 (+0.0%)
Christopher Haster